Are gamification and educational games the same thing?

Three children standing by a window looking together at a game on a tablet

One of the confusions I come across most often in our training sessions with teachers is the use of gamification and educational games as if they were the same thing. A teacher who adds a points table to their lesson says “I gamified my lesson,” and another teacher says the same thing after using an educational game. In fact these two approaches are quite different, and which one you choose directly affects the outcome in your lesson. In this post I will try to clarify this difference and touch on which approach may suit which situation.

Gamification can be defined as adding elements used in games to a context that is not a game. Points, badges, levels, leaderboards, quests and progress bars are the best-known elements of gamification. The key point is that the activity itself is not a game. Students still do the same assignments and take the same tests, but the process is wrapped in game elements.

For example, a classroom setup in which students earn points for every assignment they hand in, move up to the next level when they reach a certain score, and see their progress on the class board is a good example of gamification. The activity does not change. What changes is the motivational structure around it.

An educational game, on the other hand, is a game designed around learning objectives, with its own rules, goals and challenges. Here students really do play a game, and learning happens inside that game. A student trying to keep an ecosystem in balance in a simulation, opening doors by combining fractions in a puzzle game, or following clues to escape from a place in a virtual reality environment is playing an educational game.

In an educational game, the game elements are not decoration. They are the experience itself. The game’s mechanics reflect the knowledge or skill to be learned.

Alongside these two concepts, another term that comes up often is game-based learning. Game-based learning is a broader approach that refers to the use of games in the learning process. Besides games designed for education, using commercial games that were not designed for educational purposes in class can also be considered part of this approach. Using strategy games in a history lesson, for example, can be an instance of game-based learning.

This distinction is not just an academic debate. It has consequences that show up directly in the classroom.

Gamification is mostly about motivation. If you want to support students’ participation in an activity, their regular study habits or certain behaviors you want them to keep up, gamification can work. It is relatively easy to implement, does not require a big technical infrastructure and can easily be added to your existing lesson routine.

Educational games are about learning itself. If you want to make an abstract concept concrete, let students discover things through trial and error, or let them experience situations that would be hard or dangerous to experience in real life in a safe environment, educational games are a much more powerful option. But finding or developing a good educational game takes more time and effort.

Although gamification is useful when used well, it has some risks. The most important one is students’ attention shifting from learning to the reward. It is common to see students who pick the easiest tasks to collect points, or who stop working once they have earned a badge. That is also why the debate over whether extrinsic rewards can weaken students’ intrinsic motivation in the long run matters.

Leaderboards are another element that needs to be used carefully. While they may motivate students at the top of the table, they can have the opposite effect on those near the bottom. Rather than showing the entire class in a single ranking, progress indicators that show each student’s own growth or team-based goals usually lead to healthier results.

With educational games, the most common problem is a disconnect between the game and the learning. When the fun part of the game and the learning part are separated, students start to see the learning part as an obstacle standing in the way of the game. In that case, what you actually have is a gamified test.

Another important point is how the game is positioned within the lesson. There is a big difference between playing the game at the end of the lesson as a reward and placing it at the center of the lesson, then discussing what happened in the game afterward. The reflection and discussion after the game is the most important step in turning the experience gained in the game into knowledge.

Same topic, two different approaches

Let’s go through an example to see the difference more concretely. Say you are teaching fractions to your fourth graders.

In the gamification approach, students complete a short fractions worksheet every day. They earn points for every correct answer, and when they reach certain scores they receive badges like “Fraction Explorer” or “Fraction Master.” Each team’s progress is shown on the class board. Students fill in the worksheets more eagerly, but the work they do stays the same.

In the educational game approach, students run a pizza shop. Based on incoming orders, they need to cut pizzas into the right number of pieces, combine the slices different customers ask for and avoid wasting ingredients. A pizza cut the wrong way leaves the customer unhappy, and the student can see why right there on the pizza. Here, comparing and adding fractions is the very act of playing the game.

Both approaches can contribute to the lesson, but what goes on in the student’s mind is quite different.

Which one should you choose?

There is no single answer to this question. You can ask yourself the following:

  • Is my main problem students’ participation, or their learning of a specific concept?
  • Do I have a well-designed educational game that fits this concept?
  • Are my classroom’s technical infrastructure and lesson time suitable for playing a game?

If you are dealing with a problem of participation and consistency, you can start with well-thought-out gamification. If you are having trouble teaching a specific concept, I would suggest looking for an educational game that fits that concept, or designing a simple game together with your students. Using both approaches together is of course also possible.

Knowing the difference between gamification and educational games helps you get clear about what you are doing in class and why. Points and badges can increase students’ participation in the lesson, but they do not gamify the learning itself. A well-designed educational game, on the other hand, lets students learn while they play. Whichever approach you choose, remember to keep the learning objective at the center. Game elements are valuable as long as they serve that objective.

See you soon.

Image: Brad Flickinger, CC BY 2.0, Wikimedia Commons.