Screen time or screen quality?
Whenever children’s screen use comes up, the conversation almost always lands in the same place: how many hours a day? Time is easy to measure, so we like talking about it. Phones and tablets send us weekly reports, we see a number, and we try to decide whether it is too high or too low. But the same hour can describe very different experiences depending on what the child is actually doing. In this post I want to look at the quality of screen time without throwing the clock away entirely.
Time does matter, and I want to say that up front. For young children in particular, organizations such as the World Health Organization recommend keeping sedentary screen time limited, and none at all for babies. Those recommendations deserve to be taken seriously. As children grow, though, more and more of life, from homework to keeping in touch with friends, runs through a screen, and looking at a single number makes us miss a large part of the picture.
What happens on the screen
A child scrolling through short videos that play one after another for half an hour is not doing the same thing as a child who spends that half hour building something in a game with a friend, making a short animation, or video-calling their grandmother. In the first case the child is mostly a passive viewer. In the others they are thinking, making decisions, creating something or keeping a relationship going.
That is why it helps to think of screen activities in three rough groups. The first is consuming, such as watching or scrolling. The second is interacting, such as playing a game, solving problems in an app or researching a topic. The third is creating, such as editing a video, coding, drawing, making music or putting together a presentation. None of these is bad on its own. Watching a good documentary on a quiet evening is a perfectly valuable experience. But if nearly all of a child’s screen time falls into the first group, it is worth thinking about, even when the total looks reasonable.
The content itself matters too. Being made for children or being labeled “educational” does not make something good. Many apps sold as educational in app stores turn out to be a simple quiz wrapped in plenty of ads. When we work on educational games, one of the things we pay most attention to is keeping learning at the center and not overwhelming the child with unnecessary stimuli. When you choose content, you can look at its pace, whether it contains ads, whether it invites your child to think, and whether it has a natural ending point.
That last point matters more than it seems. Features such as autoplay and infinite scroll are designed to keep users on the screen for as long as possible. Even adults find it hard to break out of that loop, so expecting a child to do it alone is not realistic. A series that ends after one episode, a game with an ending or a project that gets finished makes turning the screen off far easier. Switching off autoplay wherever you can is a small but effective step.
With whom, and instead of what
The second dimension of screen quality is who the screen is used with. With young children especially, content watched or played together with a parent offers many more learning opportunities than content watched alone. Talking about what you see, asking “what do you think happens next,” or bringing up something you watched in everyday life the next day connects the screen experience to the real world. You do not have to sit beside your child every time, of course. But joining in now and then also helps you get to know their screen world.
A television left on in the background belongs in this discussion as well. Even when nobody seems to be watching, a screen that is on interrupts children’s play and the conversations at home. Keeping the screen on only when someone is really watching changes the sound and attention in a home more than you might expect.
It is also worth setting apart the times a screen is used to connect with others. A video call with a relative who lives far away, homework done together with a friend, or a project with classmates is a social activity, even if it happens in front of a screen. Counting this kind of use the same way as watching or scrolling sends children the wrong message about screens.
The third and perhaps most important dimension is what the screen replaces. Even if the screen is not harmful in itself, there is a problem when it takes time away from sleep, movement, outdoor play, reading or face-to-face conversation with family. My suggestion is to check first whether these basic needs are being met. If your child sleeps enough, moves during the day, spends time with friends in person and can keep themselves busy away from screens, their relationship with screens is probably in a balanced place.
To use these three dimensions day to day, you can set yourself a few checkpoints:
- I know what my child watched, played or made on a screen today.
- I have seen that the content suits their age and does not overwhelm them.
- Part of the screen time was spent together or interacting with others.
- Sleep, movement and face-to-face time did not shrink because of the screen.
There is no need to feel guilty when you look at these. Meeting every point every day is not possible. There will be sick days, long trips and busy weeks. What matters is the overall pattern.
Focusing on quality does not mean dropping time limits altogether. It actually makes them more meaningful. Instead of simply saying “one hour a day,” you can agree with your child which activities count toward that time and how homework or project time is treated. When your child starts creating something on a screen, such as an animation or a game design, giving that work a little more room is a good way to encourage making things.
When you talk with your child about screen use, ask what they think too. Helping them notice which content leaves them feeling good, and after which they feel tired or restless, lays the foundation for managing their own screen use later. Our goal is not to follow a child with a timer for life but to raise someone who can have a healthy relationship with screens.
See you soon.
Image: Shixart1985, CC BY 2.0, Wikimedia Commons.