Mayer's principles in multimedia design: a practical guide for teachers
The slides, lesson videos and worksheets teachers prepare every day are all pieces of multimedia design. Text, images, sound and sometimes animation come together. When we combine them, most of us go by intuition, and intuition sometimes misleads us. More images, more color and more information do not always mean better learning. The principles of multimedia learning that came out of many years of research by Richard Mayer and his colleagues are one of the most solid guides we have on this. In this post I want to walk through them using slides and videos, in a way you can apply directly in class.
The cognitive theory of multimedia learning behind these principles rests on three assumptions. First, people process verbal and visual information through two separate channels. Second, each channel can only handle a limited amount of information at a time. Third, learning is not passive reception but an active process in which learners select information, organize it and integrate it with what they already know. Within this framework, Mayer describes three kinds of processing that share the learner’s cognitive capacity: extraneous processing that does not serve the learning goal, essential processing caused by the inherent complexity of the content, and generative processing that learners do to make sense of the material. Good design reduces extraneous processing, keeps essential processing manageable and encourages generative processing.
Before going through the principles one by one, it is worth recalling the most basic one. The multimedia principle says people learn better from words and pictures together than from words alone. This does not mean decorative pictures. It means diagrams, charts and images that explain what is being taught. A stock photo on a slide and a diagram showing a process step by step do not do the same job.
Reducing extraneous load
The coherence principle says people learn better when material that does not serve the learning goal is left out. Interesting but off-topic anecdotes, decorative images, background music and animated transitions all fall into this category. Once your slides are ready, asking of every element “does this help my students understand the topic?” is the most practical way to apply this principle. When we design interfaces for educational games, filtering screen elements with that same question is one of the things we do most often.
The signaling principle shows that designs which highlight essential information and make the structure of the content visible support learning. Pointing with an arrow to the part of a diagram you are talking about, highlighting a key term in a different color, or briefly listing the three main sections at the start of a video are all examples of signaling. The thing to watch is proportion. Highlighting everything has the same effect as highlighting nothing.
The redundancy principle is one of the most misunderstood. According to it, people learn better from graphics and narration than from graphics, narration and the same text printed on screen. Reading aloud a long text that is also on the screen forces learners to follow both the image and the text with their eyes and to compare what they read with what they hear. This does not mean text has to go entirely. A few short key words on screen usually cause no problem. Printed text can also help when there are no graphics, when the presentation is slow-paced, or when learners are not native speakers of the language. My suggestion is to use key words and visuals on your slides rather than writing down everything you are going to say.
The spatial contiguity principle says related words and pictures should be placed near each other on the screen. A student trying to match the parts of a diagram with a list of explanations at the bottom of the slide spends mental capacity moving their eyes back and forth instead of understanding the topic. Putting labels right next to the relevant part of the diagram is a simple but effective fix. The temporal contiguity principle is the same idea applied to time. When explaining an animation, giving the narration and the visuals at the same time works better than showing the animation first and explaining it afterwards.
Managing essential processing and supporting understanding
The segmenting principle shows that breaking complex content into parts that learners can move through at their own pace supports learning. Making short videos that each focus on one idea instead of one long lesson video, or pausing briefly after each step in a live explanation, are ways to apply it. The pre-training principle says it helps to introduce the names and characteristics of key concepts before explaining a process. Introducing the parts of an engine before explaining how it works stops learners from wrestling with new terms while they are also trying to follow the process.
The modality principle shows that supporting graphics with narration rather than printed text helps learning, especially in fast-paced, complex presentations. The reason is that images and printed text share the same visual channel. Narration moves information to the other channel and balances the load. For long, technical information that learners need to go back and reread, however, printed text may be the better choice.
The personalization principle says a conversational style works better than a formal one. Addressing learners as “you” and “we” in your videos helps them feel a social connection with the speaker and put in more effort. The voice principle says narration in a human voice works better than a machine voice. The image principle points to a striking finding: having the speaker’s face on screen the whole time does not by itself improve learning. So not having your own image in the corner of your lesson video is not a shortcoming. What matters is the content on the screen.
That finding does not mean there should never be a speaker on screen. The embodiment principle says that when an on-screen instructor or animated character uses human-like gestures, points to what is being explained and makes eye contact, learning benefits. In short, the speaker’s presence adds nothing on its own, but it helps when it directs learners’ attention to the right place. A teacher in a whiteboard video who points to what they are talking about is far more useful than a talking face in the corner.
Not all of these principles work equally well in every situation. Research shows their effects are strongest for learners who are new to a topic. For students who already know the topic well, some kinds of support become unnecessary and can even slow learning down. So it is better to treat the principles not as strict rules but as design recommendations you adjust to your audience.
You do not need to apply every principle at once when you prepare your next slide deck. You can start by removing unnecessary elements, cutting long on-screen text down to key words and moving labels next to the images they describe. Even these three small changes will noticeably increase the mental capacity your students can devote to what you are teaching.
See you soon.